From the category archives:

Education Blogging

Despite the Fact… Blogging Conferences

by Dr Davis on September 30, 2011

Despite the fact that today I attended a regional conference which I really enjoy and am going to post the notes from several sessions, I am frustrated. It’s the same kerfuffle…

Once again I received an email asking me to take down a post that was a live blogging of a session.

Really? You want to present to hundreds of people but you don’t want me to write about it? You want us to talk about it, to remember you, to link to your work, but you don’t want me to blog about it? You want to get feedback, hear what people hear you saying, and hopefully add another line to your CV, but you don’t want me to blog about it?

At least this one wasn’t the evil, threatening version. Instead it was somewhat clueless.

I have several objections to having this posted online, one of which is the fact that the images presented are not my own. I feel this is an unethical misrepresentation of information. Also, because the blog only includes bits and pieces of my ideas, I would prefer to not have something that is so sporadic and discombobulated associated with my name without my knowledge and consent. I have since further developed this paper and do not wish for the beginning stages of it to be presented online. I am also in the process of having it copywrited.

Two grammar errors. A vocabulary issue. A spelling error. An insult to my writing notes. She now knows it’s associated with her name, so that takes one point away. She doesn’t want the beginnings out there, even though she presented them. (Yes, I know a conference presentation is seen as more ephemeral. Online is forever. Wouldn’t that be good? Her stuff is readable forever.)

Then there is the fact that notes as news reporting and scholarship are allowed as fair use, even if the work is copyrighted, which it might be immediately upon presentation. Fair use allows me to use the work without the author’s permission for reporting or scholarship.

Would it have made her less upset if I had noted that the images were mine? Probably not. That just gave her one more point to talk about in the email.

I like to write about conferences. People writing about conferences is what introduced me to some of my favorites.

I don’t like getting email from people saying take my notes down. You know what, this isn’t your paper. It’s my notes. If I take your name off of it, will that make it better? If your name isn’t on it, you won’t be able to google it. So maybe from now on when I blog conference presentations, I should not put the person’s name on it. Instead I will say S-D- from BU spoke. Then most people won’t notice that I blogged their posts. And if they don’t notice that they were blogged, they won’t ask me to take them down.

Is it more ethical for me to take someone’s name off, while giving you enough information on both the conference and their university that you could find them if you wanted, or to leave my post up even when someone wants it taken down?

These are NOT their conference presentations. These are my notes. They are not the same thing. They do not belong to the person presenting. They belong to me.

I won’t present their papers anywhere, but I want to be able to put my notes on their papers up. I can see, though, how having my notes up may feel like I am misappropriating their papers. They can’t control them. (Of course they can’t control them in other environments either, they just don’t see them as easily there.) I personally would prefer to see the notes up with my name attached than out there floating in internet space without my name on them.

Yes, I realize other people may take them and use them and not put your name on them. But they could do that following your presentation.

Too bad there aren’t a thousand folks telling me about how my blog got their work out and someone contacted them because of the notes on my blog.

{ 4 comments }

Google Analytics: The Numbers are Mostly Up

by Dr Davis on August 30, 2011

creating and maintaining a professional blog, which, according to Google Analytics, in the last year had
63,206 visitors
75,118 visits
131,350 pageviews

I wrote this in February for my New Media Experience post.

Today I thought I would check Google Analytics for the last year for TCE. It says:
106,691 visitors
124,868 visits
194,394 pageviews

So almost twice as many visitors and twice as many visits, but only 50% more pageviews. (Okay, that’s very round estimation. I’ll call my actuary son for more complete math later.)

TCE has had 8.5% less visitors this month than last. I’m guessing that is because school has been mostly out. Snape as Byronic Hero has had 2000+ visits… I can’t believe that many people are looking for that, but it was a very interesting presentation.

Still, it does mean that TCE is getting quite a bit of traffic.

Also, the website I put up for my old college had 200+ hits and has not had any content added since April when I gave notice.

Which reminds me, I promised to get the website for a conference together. Hmm. Must finish chapter first.

{ 0 comments }

Reading Through TCE

by Dr Davis on August 27, 2011

I’ve been reading through TCE looking at ideas I logged here that I no longer remember. There are lots of good ones. Really.

Gotta get a hold of the teacher eval form my new college uses. That would be very useful.

Soon (maybe) I will post a link fest of links that I used this start of the semester.

{ 0 comments }

+145%

by Dr Davis on August 1, 2011

This last eight months, compared to the same eight months last year, traffic to TCE has more than doubled. According to Google Analytics, I have gone from 30,011 visits to 73,749.

The top ranked articles are still the same. Students want to know how to write a character analysis and teachers want to know more about informal assessments.

However, the 5th most popular title is new to this year, as it is a post on a conference presentation. PCA: Conteuses and Sex in the City Movie has had over 4,000 page views since it was posted in April. If it stays at that rate, it will soon be second, displacing the informal assessments post.

{ 0 comments }

New TA Starts Blog

by Dr Davis on July 28, 2011

EnglishTA is going to be blogging his experience with a brand new teaching assistantship in warm climes.

Even if he didn’t understand the point of “teaching heavy” (in this post), it will be an interesting experience.

Since he appears to have no commenting ability enabled, I will respond here.

Dear John:
I did not apply to R1 schools to work as I am a teacher, not primarily a researcher. Thus, your negative response to teaching heavy relates more to your experience with your professor than to my post.

What I was saying is that 200+ people applied to a position which is often looked down on by the academic community (since it is teaching heavy, which requires an incredible time commitment–especially in composition), which, I would expect, means that 1000s applied to the one or two SLAC, R2, and R1 jobs that were posted in my city.

Anyone who reads this blog for very long knows I love my students and my teaching. But they also know that I have experienced the discrimination against teaching in the academy.

I, too, taught high school. Yes, I prefer college teaching to that. However, it is not because it is easier, but because I have more control over my classroom and (as you mentioned) don’t usually have to deal with parents. (Let’s just say that ambassadors, state senators, etc, can get administration to override even FERPA. Though I won’t do it, I am required to give the info to admin who then does it themselves.)

I’ve taught 6/6/3, so I think I should be able to speak about teaching heavy without being the bad guy.

{ 1 comment }

Surviving English Class in College

by Dr Davis on July 7, 2011

from CampusSplash:

What do you feel are some mistakes that most students in English courses make?
“A big mistake is that most students think about the page requirement for an essay rather than about the quality of the essay. If students write to a page limit, they end up putting a lot of filler in their essays. When students concentrate on developing their ideas, then the page requirement takes care of itself.”

This is pretty good.

I might use it with my freshman English classes.

{ 3 comments }

Minimal Blogging

by Dr Davis on June 26, 2011

I am in the process of moving from Big City with great Community College that I worked in this last year to smaller town with wonderful Small Liberal Arts College.

That means I am busy, calling insurance agents (again and again), trying to get gas turned on, figuring out why the water pressure is too low to water the lawn on the ration day, etc. So I won’t be doing a lot of blogging.

I am going to try to pre-post short things here that I found interesting, but there will be limited commentary, I expect, until I am officially moved August 1.

{ 0 comments }

What would it take?

by Dr Davis on June 17, 2011

What would it take for an upscale proprietary college/university to succeed?

Community College Dean looks at Britain’s newest proprietary college, which has, he believes a flawed business model.

Then he offers an alternative model:

An upscale proprietary could work, I suspect, if it combined very selective admissions with low class sizes, an extremely narrow set of curricular choices, hotel-style student housing, and a clear identity. The “hear occasional lectures by famous people” hook won’t cut it, since anyone who wants to can go online and subscribe to TED talks for free. The structure would have to be intensely student-centered, with the hook being something like “project-based from day one.” The value proposition, aside from the self-fulfilling value of exclusivity, would be that if offers what the online world can’t. I’m envisioning something close to “spend four years in close quarters with smart people doing self-directed projects.”

Is this what a good SLAC should be aiming for? I wonder.

It’s something for me to consider as I move back into the tenure track at a small liberal arts college.

{ 0 comments }

College Students, Value of College, Etc.

by Dr Davis on June 10, 2011

A Pew Research Study shows some interesting things about college that I think English professors might be interested in.

Are students getting worse?
First, it found that college presidents don’t think students today are as good as students of yesteryear.

A 58%-majority of college presidents say public high school students arrive at college less well prepared than students of a decade ago. Just 6% say public high schools are doing a better job at preparing students for college than a decade ago, while 36% say they are doing about the same job. Once the students are settled on campus, the outlook remains equally pessimistic. More than half of college presidents (52%) say today’s students are studying less than students did a decade ago. Only 7% say students are studying more, and 40% say students are doing about the same amount of studying as college students did 10 years ago.

What do we think the value of college is, in general and in particular?
The study also showed that:

A majority of Americans (57%) say the higher education system in the United States fails to provide students with good value for the money they and their families spend. An even larger majority (75%) says college is too expensive for most Americans to afford. At the same time, however, an overwhelming majority of college graduates (86%) say that college has been a good investment for them personally.

Monetary Payoff. Adults who graduated from a four-year college believe that, on average, they are earning $20,000 more a year as a result of having gotten that degree. Adults who did not attend college believe that, on average, they are earning $20,000 a year less as a result. These matched estimates by the public are very close to the median gap in annual earnings between a high school and college graduate as reported by the U.S. Census Bureau in 2010: $19,550.

So we like it ourselves, but think it doesn’t do a good job for other people. It’s too expensive, but way more people are going. If you go, you make more money. If you don’t, you are less likely to make money.

Perception is clearly at odds with reality.

Why go to college?

Just under half of the public (47%) says the main purpose of a college education is to teach work-related skills and knowledge, while 39% say it is to help a student grow personally and intellectually; the remainder volunteer that both missions are equally important. College graduates place more emphasis on intellectual growth; those who are not college graduates place more emphasis on career preparation.

{ 2 comments }

Final Grades

by Dr Davis on June 2, 2011

Since finals were recent and many people are talking/writing about them (and since I hadn’t read any blogs for about a month), I am a bit late to CCDean’s party on “Final Grade Windows.”

CCDean has a point that I agree with in this particular post:

If it were up to me, the answer would be to do away with final exams as final exams, and to have classes run to the bitter end. But the folks who like to give “common” finals across sections don’t like that — they have a point — and the folks who effectively start vacation a week early would prefer not to rock the boat. Between the two groups, it’s hard to get critical mass for a change.

I think that I may be agitating for either two “common” finals for second semester freshman comp OR for identifying the exam as an “exit essay” worth 10% and NOT list it as a final exam.

Yes, I know that is rhetorically hiding the pea, but still… It would allow me as a rhetorician to focus primarily on rhetorial analysis and to do the final 10% of class on poetry analysis.

{ 0 comments }